TRAVEL AGENT RISK MANAGEMENT WEBINAR
Click here to go back to Top of Page

In December 2008, Jeff Miller served as the Webinar keynote speaker for luxury travel network Virtuoso, the by-invitation-only organization comprising over 300 agencies with more than 6,000 elite travel specialists in 22 countries, as well as over 1,000 of the world’s best travel providers and premier destinations. Jeff was introduced by David Hansen, Virtuoso’s executive vice president operations and finance.

David Hansen:
Hey, thank you guys for being here. I need to - I appreciate everybody’s time this afternoon. We had a very successful seminar this morning that Jeff put on - a Webinar actually. And those who don’t know Jeff let me give a brief introduction to him before I turn it over to him.

Jeff brings about 30 years worth of legal and business expertise to the role and he’s the founder and principal of the The Miller Travel Group and also Lipshultz and Miller P.A.

He consistently maintains an AV rating by Martindale-Hubbell which is the governing body - the highest level awarded based on a peer review of ethical standards and legal ability.

He served for years as an adjunct professor of graduate business courses at the University of Maryland. He’s the author of numerous travel industry textbooks and publications. He’s contributed numerous articles to leading travel industry publications - you probably have read him online or in print. And he is a very sought after speaker in regards to business and civic groups on topics of concern to the traveling public.

Jeff is a very straight to the point presenter and I think you’ll really enjoy his session this afternoon, and hopefully learn quite a bit in regards to risk management during these uncertain times. Jeff.

Jeff Miller:
Thank you David. I’d like to thank you and Matthew for inviting me. And the way we’re going to do the format is the same as we did this morning. We’ll do about 35 minutes of a presentation and 25 minutes of Q&A.

Basically the environment that we’re in at this time the economy, nobody has really lived through this in our generation. It’s uncertain times and the key, from the travel agency perspective as well as from many other industries, is to learn what your risks are and take steps to protect your agencies from those risks.

The key is when the economic cycle eventually turns, and it always will, is to be in a financially stable position at that point to then be able to substantially grow and enhance your revenues.

You're going to keep in mind that in the times we’re in there will be suppliers that go out of business, and I’m - throughout this Webinar I’m not mentioning anybody by name or implying anybody, I‘m using everything generically.

But the key here is to protect yourself. And the way you really protect yourself primarily is to use disclaimers. That’s the first thing that you should do is to use disclaimers. And a disclaimer can range from a very detailed document to a very short and sweet document if you will. I recommend the shorter, the simpler, and in plain English, the better.

And at the very least, a disclaimer will potentially protect you in court. I’ve had clients tell me well, a judge is going to throw out the disclaimer. If a disclaimer is reasonable it could very well defend you in court. And to make it reasonable is to make sure that the client is aware of it, they’ve read it, they’ve understood it.

Now the first question that somebody would ask me was, is well how do you get somebody to sign it when we don’t see our clients in person.

Well there are several ways to do that and electronic signatures are good. The old days 20 years ago I’d be sitting at your desk and I would sign it as I picked up my documents; that doesn’t happen today in the real world in the travel industry.

So the key to the disclaimer is to make it available to the client and make sure that the client acknowledges receipt of it in some manner. Now the absolutely best way to have a disclaimer is if you can - if you’re selling a tour and or package or a cruise, you add the insurance to the package. And you say, for example, if the cruise is $1000 and the insurance is $100, this cost is $1100. If you don’t want the insurance, just send us back the $1000 or signify you don’t want the insurance by just paying $1000.

That is better than a signature because it’s an action. An action is better than words and that alone is a disclaimer. So that’s very, very important to keep that in mind if you can do that.

The only problem with that is in some of your states, not many but a few, the State Insurance Commissioners will not allow you to add the insurance in to the package automatically. So you need to check with either your State Insurance Commissioner or more likely just ask your insurance rep whether it’s allowed in your state. It is the most effective way of getting a disclaimer.

You don’t need a signature, it’s an action, and keep in mind that most people will accept it which is what you want because it not only enhances revenue, but it protects everybody.

Now let me say one thing about insurance. When I use the word insurance that implies that it’s been approved by your State Insurance Commissioner and there is financial stability. We have situations where there are tour protection offered by the tour supplier themselves. That’s not insurance. And unfortunately there’s been many court cases over the years where a travel agent sold tour protection and the person thought they had insurance; the tour operator went out of business and the protection went with them.

So I always recommend you can sell whatever insurance company you want or whatever your preferred insurance company is, but I always recommend that you sell an insurance product.

And as pointed out on the Webinar this morning, some of the insurance - some of the vendors will sell something labeled tour protection, but it’s underwritten by an insurance company. As long as it’s underwritten by an insurance company it’s fine because that means there is financial stability. But that’s very important to see what you’re selling.

Now the other question is, if I can’t get the person to acknowledge it, what do I do about that? And you’d have to have some policies and procedures in place to protect your agency. And the key situation where this arises is on most of your policies, if you don’t take the policy within 7 to 21 days from the date of the deposit, then you waive any pre-existing medical conditions.

And the problem with that is, I’m your client, I take the insurance, and 30 days later I send back the premium and say I want the insurance. And I have just waived all pre-existing conditions, but you never told me that because either you didn’t have a policy and procedures in place to review it when it comes back in or to follow up on it.

So I have a bad back, I have a cruise scheduled for nine months from now, I have surgery to my back a month before the cruise, I have no protection under the policy; I will guarantee you the agency’s going to get sued.

Now your Errors and Omissions Insurance may protect you, but there’s no winners in litigation but lawyers. It’s very aggravating, stressful and it takes you away from your livelihood which is to try to generate revenue and satisfy your clients because you’re defending a lawsuit with your insurance company.

So what I strongly recommend is that you have a policy in place which says specifically, please be advised that you have to return this policy to us within 7 to 21 days -- depending upon what your individual policy says -- if you want to waive any pre-existing medicals conditions.

Knowing that if it comes back after that, your staff or the agent that’s working with him or however you set up your office, has to notify your client we’ve received your form, I want to let you know that you have waived any pre-existing medical conditions, and before I process this form with the insurance carrier, I want to make absolutely certain you still want the insurance.

And please don’t ever ask medical information of your clients. It’s confidential, it proprietary, it’s protected by federal law as most of you on what’s called HIPAA. So you don’t want that information; you’re just making the person available.

If the person comes back and says, well I have some specific questions about the insurance, the way to handle that is you could either put them directly in touch with your insurance broker or your insurance agent, or you can get a written question from them by email and just forward it on to the insurance company.

You should never do something off the cuff; you should never try to answer an insurance question because it could expose you to significant liability. And any time that you, you know, change one fact you could change the result and you’re not in the insurance business and that’s what the insurance companies are there for.

And the major litigation that arises out of insurance - issuance of insurance policies is the pre-existing condition clauses. And I’ve probably seen a dozen cases in the last 12 months and in each case the agency was responsible because they never notified the person that they had waived the pre-existing condition. So there was no notification procedures at all.

And particularly if you use independent contractors, and for our purposes for the next 50 minutes, if you give the person a 1099 they’re an independent contractor. That’s our definition for this session.

If you use independent contractors you have to have the same kind of policies and procedures in place to make certain that there’s no issues because the agency would have liability.

If you’re dealing with a group, please keep in mind that if it’s a group of a charity group or a religious organization or a school group, the leader of the group cannot sign the disclaimer on behalf of the group. It has to be signed by the individual participants.

So in those situations, if at all possible, you want to put the insurance into the trip and just put it in and don’t give them an option to opt out; again, if your state allows that. But that makes it a very simple procedure because the group leader cannot sign a disclaimer for anybody on the group.

Also keep in mind with regard to disclaimers, if the people are not legally married, they can’t sign for each other. Or if they’re not minor children they can’t sign for each other. So may need disclaimers for more than one person.

Now somebody is going to tell me if we were actually in an auditorium somewhere would say, well that’s not practical and that’s impossible. And that’s probably true, but all I can do is give you ideas with regard to guidance and then you have to make business decisions as to which works for your agency.

They may work for one agency and not for another, or you may want to take that risk depending on what the group is. But you need to at least know what the risk is and then make a business decision as to whether you want to protect yourself or not. I mean that’s what’s extremely important.

And the disclaimer should be written in very plain English, it should be - the person should be able to understand it. You want something that says in the disclaimer that we strongly recommend that you use credit cards to pay for the trip. You’re never going to guarantee to a client that if you charge to a credit card you’re totally protected because that’s not true.

But if you look at your credit card statement -- it comes every month on the back of it -- that’s the Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and it provides your rights. Generally, if you don’t get what you pay for, or if you’ve already paid for it and you didn’t get it, you’re either going to get a credit back to your account or you’re going to get - you don’t have to pay the bill. And then the credit card company has to deal with the vendor.

Under no circumstances do you want to tell a client that you’re absolutely guaranteed by charging to a credit card. On the other hand, you definitely tell them not to use a debit card because there is virtually no protection to a debit card. There’s no protection if they pay with cash or check.

So it’s very, very important in the disclaimer that you put in one line that says, our agency strongly recommends that you use a credit card to pay for these services.

Also in the disclaimer you have to advise your client that we are an agent acting as a principal for -- and you can list the airline or the cruise line or the various suppliers -- however you decide you want to do the disclaimer to keep it as short as possible. But it’s very important that you notify them that you are an agent of a principal, and therefore the principal’s responsible if there is a problem; the agent isn’t.

And a lot of times I’ve seen disclaimers that are done and the agents forget to put that in. That should be in the first line - ABC Travel Agency is an agent of XYZ Airline or cruise line or whatever it is you happen to be selling and it makes it much easier that way.

So, a key - and I wouldn’t have had this session talking about credit cards ten years ago, but you really need to make absolutely certain that you recommend credit cards. If they don’t want to use them that’s up to them, but it’s very important that you use them.

And debit cards are a potential problem. They aren’t protected generally by federal law the way credit cards are because basically the legislation has not caught up with the marketplace. So I would not recommend having you use a - have a client use a debit card if at all possible.

We deal now with signature on file and I’m going to disregard for a second signature on file with regard to ARC. If you sell airline tickets and you look at the Industry Agent’s Handbook, in the back of it, depending on the credit card company and depending upon the airline, they have specific requirements.

We’re going to deal with non-airline signature on file. And basically, if I tell you to book a cruise for me and I send you an email which says I hereby authorize you to charge $1500 to my Visa card, account number, expiration date, billing address, security code on the back, that’s valid.

And you could enforce that charge against me in the event that I refuse to pay for some reason. And under no circumstances should you ever take the client’s credit card, run it through your merchant agreement, and then remit to the vendor.

And having said that I know many of you do that, I have clients that do that every day. There is no greater risk to your agency, and I have some - I know people that are former client’s; they’re no longer in business because they ran into such financial problems doing that.

If I’m the client and you take my credit card and you run it through your merchant agreement because you’re looking for cash flow issues, particularly if it’s a consolidator ticket, you’ve marked it up, there’s a service fee attached to it, some kind of professional fee attached to it, and you run through your merchant agreement and I have a problem and I try to reverse the charge, even though the vendor caused the problem, the charge is going to be reversed to the agency’s credit card agreement.

And therefore if I wind up not paying for the trip, you’re stuck.

And you don’t have virtually any rights against the principal because the Fair Credit Reporting Act talks about consumers and your agency would not be a consumer under those circumstances.

Now I know agencies do this every day; I know they do it for cash flow purposes, and that’s a business decision. But if I told you the greatest risk that you have today, in this economy with this - the world that we’re living in, is if you run client’s charges through your merchant agreement. If you want to remit it directly, straight through to the vendor, then that provides the most maximum protection that you could get.

And most vendors will accept, you know, authorization by email, anything like that. Some of them have very specific requirements, but other than the airlines, most don’t as long as you have something writing, which is an authorization that allows you to charge.

Also it’s extremely important that you require your agents and your independent contractors to offer travel insurance to your clients. Now how do you enforce that - you enforce that through policies and procedures. For every booking - and I’m not talking about the sale of an airline ticket, we’re talking about a cruise, a tour - something like that -- a package -- you either have a disclaimer that’s signed or you have an insurance policy in effect.

And then you have to decide, well the client says that won’t sign and they don’t want the insurance, then that’s a business decision whether you want to continue with that sale. But I will assure you, a reasonable person will not refuse to sign if they don’t want the insurance. And if they refuse to sign, they’ll be the first person to see you if there’s a problem. So that’s generally what you would try to do.

How do you force an independent contractor to do that, well you always have a control issue with independent contractors which is beyond the scope of our presentation this afternoon? But basically you tell the person when you do a booking, we either need a disclaimer or we need an insurance policy.

And if the person consistently doesn’t follow those procedures then you have to make some business decisions as to where you want to go with that. But you have some inherent risks in using independent contractors because you can’t control what they do, even - there’s many, many of them that are successful.

So you really want to sort of watch that issue and decide what you want to do from a policy and procedures standpoint with regard to the independent contractor and the issuance of policies.

In the disclaimer, on the last line, I typically like to put in language which says, I have read this disclaimer, I understand the disclaimer, and any questions concerning the disclaimer have been answered to my satisfaction. Generally the person has not read anything, they just sign it. But at least they’ve confirmed that they have read it and they do understand it.

A good disclaimer should be no more than a page; a lot of them can be two paragraphs - it depends on what it’s being used for. In a couple of minutes we’ll talk about high risk travel and travel to hot spots and things of that nature, so that many be a different scenario.

You don’t have to worry about E&O insurance; it’s a requirement of Virtuoso membership. I recommend that you have a deductible which is the self insurance equal to the amount of a small claims award in your state, and basically you would self ensure for the small claims amount.

Regardless of the deductible amount the insurance carrier has to protect you with legal fees - lawyers. They pick the lawyers for you and they defend you. So that’s regardless of the amount you take. Obviously the higher the deductible, the lower the premium.

And you want to try to make sure that your E&O policy will include bankruptcy or default of suppliers. Some do and some don’t - I’m not sure, you know, what anybody uses - what particular company, but if possible you want to do that. I think that’s very, very important to protect you.

I had a question this morning, somebody said well suppose it’s an incentive group with a disclaimer. Under an incentive group you should be able to put into the contract, the travel insurance, so it shouldn’t be an issue of getting individual signatures from participants. It should be fairly easy to just put it in to the cost of the trip; it protects the group, it protects the individual.

So, I mean I think that’s something that you really want to look out for and try to protect yourself under those kinds of circumstances.

And we had a lot of questions this morning that were really pretty good when we get to that.

Also hitting just some other hot spot topics that may be of interest as we go through this material, you need to make certain that you have a written agreement with your independent contractors. The written agreement -- three to four pages at the most. If you have an attorney draw it up, they draw up one and then you fill in the blanks for name, financial consideration, the rest of it’s the format. You do two copies, there’s two originals - one for the independent contractor; one for the agency.

You want to make certain -- because the contract should be fair to both parties, and you just don’t want any misunderstandings -- so you want to make certain that it talks about commission levels, or you want to make sure it has a confidentiality provision in it. There cannot be a restrictive covenant in an independent contractor agreement because the person is not an employee.

You can have a confidentiality agreement which says you can’t basically take our client list; you can’t take our proprietary information and use it to compete with us. That is enforceable in virtually any state.

You also want information as to how often or how far back can the independent contractor claim commissions. If they don’t claim it within 90 days then they waive that right.

You want to know how often commissions will be paid; you wanted to know if there’s offsets because there’s been problems with bookings - can the agency offset any liability against the independent contractor - very common language. You can take it out of commissions, due and owing; if there’s not enough there you can try to get back from the person - it’s very difficult to do.

Because I will guarantee you that if there’s a problem booked through an independent contractor, even if you have what’s called an indemnification agreement with the independent contractor, the harmed passenger or the alleged harm is coming after the agency. So that’s what called the deep-pocket for the people that would have fund, not the independent contractor.

And then you may or may not be able to go after the independent contractor depending on what kind of action has taken place, but you really want a written agreement that locks in parties rights. And you want to make certain that the independent contractor is not binding the agency to contracts without your knowledge. That’s very important - you don’t want to allow this person to go out and sign agreements which may not be beneficial to the agency. And so you have to have language in the agreement that will protect both parties.

Also there’s usually a question of what should be on a business card, and you could ask ten lawyers questions and you’ll get 15 opinions. I basically say it should be Jeff Miller, and affiliate of, or an independent contractor of XYZ Travel. I like to have that extra language in there as opposed to just saying, Jeff Miller, working with ABC Travel because it implies that I may be an employee and that poses different liability issues for the agency.

Also, if you see a client in your house and you don’t have what’s called a business - occasional business use rider, R-I-D-E-R to your policy - home owner’s policy there’s probably no insurance.

So if you’re going to see clients in your house sporadically, I know that we pay $75 a year for that - my wife’s an interior designer - she’s had her business in our house for 40 years. So on our home owners’ policy we have an occasional business use of an interior design office and its $75 a year.

So if one of her clients comes to the house, trips and falls, it’s covered. If I came to your house to pick up travel documents, you didn’t have that coverage and the insurance asked me what I was doing there, and I say I’m picking up documents, they’ll say there’s no coverage on their home owner’s because it’s a business and you didn’t tell them that.

Also if you’re delivering tickets in your personal car or documents in your personal car, and you’re not covered under the agencies general liability policy, then you want to make sure you have occasional business use on your automobile insurance. It may raise the premium a little bit, but it provides a lot of protection.

And again, that’s going to be a business decision or a personal decision. I can only tell you as a lawyer what you need to look at and then you make the decision whether that’s economic or not. I can tell you that the most frustrating thing in the world would be to have insurance and then find out that it doesn’t cover your situation.

And I must talk about for a second travel to hot spots. You get people - actually we’re going to go back because I skipped something. We’re gong to go back to the baggage policies on the disclaimers as you can see, what’s up there now with Jungle Air.

With all the policies today that exist for most of the airlines with regard to baggage fees, cancellation fees, change fees, we recommend that there be a line or two in the disclaimer that says, you are booked on XYZ Airline. As of this time they have a baggage fee or whatever the fee happens to be, and you need to be aware of that.

You don’t want a situation where the people aren’t aware of that, they get to the airport and find out they have eight pieces of luggage for four passengers and it costs them $200 to get on the plane and $200 to come back.

It’s very simple. One of the questions that was raised this morning, well if it’s a certain policy at this time and it changes by the time they travel, you know, how do you protect yourself. You merely say at the time that you’re traveling there is a policy in effect; it may be subject to change.

As a practical matter I’m not aware of any airline that has charged a fee to anybody who was booked prior to the implementation of the fee. I don’t think the U.S. Department of Transportation would allow that. I know from personal experience -- I have children and grandchildren in Seattle that came to the East Coast on Alaska Airlines; they had booked prior to Alaska implementing the fees. There was no problem when they went to check in; they were allowed free baggage. It was in the PNR that they had booked prior to the implementation and they were allowed to check baggage without any arguments or hassles whatsoever.

And I thinks that’s true with all the airlines that charge fees or have charged fees and then raised the fees. There’s usually a start date for anything booked after that date. Anything other than that I think would be a deceptive trade practice which we would (unintelligible) by the government.

But I think the airlines - I think they’ve cooperated at least with regard to that issue because they realize that’s what’s reasonable. I had forgotten to cover that until I looked at the Webcast.

And we have high risk travel. The only key issue here is if you’re selling high risk travel, you want to say, preferably in writing, to your client, here’s a description of what you’re going to do or where you’re going and we so would strongly recommend that at least you sit down with your family physician or your family doctor and say, hey am I physically capable of doing this.

Under no circumstances do you want to know their medical condition at all; you never want to know that. All you’re suggesting to them is hey, this is what’s involved; this is where you’re going, it’s strenuous, can you don this; and check with our family doctor to make certain.

Probably with situations like this you also want to sell medical evacuation insurance. Sometimes it’s included as part of the travel insurance policy. There are companies out there that will sell you the insurance - medical evac coverage for a year at a time so it will cover multiple trips.

Many of them are commissionable to the industry, and that may predict more protection. But somebody who’s doing high risk travel has more potential to get hurt seriously and may have to be MedEvac’d out, which would be very expensive if you had to do it.

Again, I’m not talking about a whole paragraph - one line. We gave you the brochure that describes the high risk travel, and we recommended that you contact your medical provider to make certain that you can do it.

Travel to hot spots - unfortunately today as we’ve seen the catastrophe in the Far East recently, there is no guarantee of what may be a hot spot today; it wasn't yesterday or vice versa. But there are certainly places where if your client is going to travel, you need to be aware of it and provide some guidance.

I would generally say I would never give guidance to a potential passenger as to what the risk factor is, on a hot spot travel I would say we’d recommend you go to the Web site of the U.S. State Department and they have advisories. I would never substitute my judgment for that because whatever you told the person, if there was a problem, they heard something else. And whatever they heard is going to provide a problem to your agency.

So the U.S. State Department provides that; there are clearly private companies out there that provide security data. I don’t recommend that the agency ever make any statements whatsoever about safety or security at any location.

If a person wants to go there and you knew it was a very serious issue of security then you may want to put a line in to the disclaimer, you know, you’re going there we’ve suggested you check the Web site.

I used an example this morning when they were kidnapping Americans in Lebanon in the late 70s. I had a travel agency client call me; they had a client in their office who wanted to book a trip to Lebanon which he couldn’t legally go from the U.S., but you could route it through Montreal.

And they said, “What should I do? Should I sell him a ticket?” And I said, “The risk is too great to sell him a ticket. There’s kidnapping of Americans and other foreigners. Just tell them you’re not going to sell them the ticket. And if you really wanted to cause a problem, tell them there’s an agency on the street that specializes in that kind of travel and send them there. Otherwise just tell them you can’t book it or you won’t book it.”

The risk is too great that if there was a problem that you would get sued. And even if you win -- again, there are no winners in litigation but the lawyers; it’s very time consuming and very, very stressful.

Your client list and your name are your most important assets. You need to protect your client lists under any circumstances and you can do that primarily as I mentioned in the Independent Contractor Agreement. You can clearly do it with your employees through your Policy and Procedures Manual. You don’t need that in - most of you do not have employment agreements with front line staff; it’s very unusual in this industry. It’s unusual for a lot of managers.

But you can clearly protect yourself through a Policies and Procedures Manual which states, you know, that this information is proprietary; it can’t be disclosed. If in fact you disclose it or if in fact you take it with you and compete with us, you authorize us to contact the agency where you’re presently working and advise them of this restriction.

You’d be amazed at how often that doesn’t exist and the person walked out the door and goes next door or goes across the street or today it could be across town or across the country and still competes with you. That is your most valuable asset. It’s your most valuable asset in business, it’s your most valuable asset if you ever decide to sell, and you need to protect it.

A Trade Secrets Agreement which is similar to a Confidentiality Agreement - depending on which lawyer is drafting it and how they word it, will protect your client list; it will protect your supplier contracts - your supplier contacts, things of that nature.

So that’s really the key to protecting your agency is to do your homework and have these policies and procedures in effect. And what we recommend is you just do an internal risk management audit on yourself, maybe with your CPA, and just go over some of these things. And just make sure that you have these things in place or you say well, I’ve heard that and I don’t really want to do that, but at least you’ve been made aware of it and you can make an informed decision whether it will be helpful to you or harmful to you.

I think eventually as we all know, the market will turn. The question is, you know, how many agencies will still be around; how many suppliers will still be around, and if you take steps to protect yourself, you should be. The problem is that you could run into some risk management issues that could cause severe economic harm to your agency despite the economy. And that’s why you need to protect yourself.

And I didn’t mention it, but I’m assuming most are all of you are either corporations or limited liability corporations or limited liability partnerships and very few of you are sole proprietorships.

It’s very common today for the independent contractors to be incorporated. They might have closed down a brick and mortar agency and moved to their home location, but they kept their corporation.

Keep in mind that if the independent contractor is incorporated, they can’t be on the agencies Errors & Omissions policy, they need their own policy. That’s the only thing that you have to keep in mind. There would be no coverage under the agencies policy for an independent contractor who is incorporated.

Read Jeff’s quote on the closing of airport lounges featured on the front page of the International Herald Tribune, July 28 - Download PDF
Click here to go back to Top of Page

Elite airport lounges are falling victim to airline industry downturn
By Jane L. Levere | Published by International Herald Tribune: July 28, 2008

NEW YORK: Membership lounges at airports are the latest casualty of the current crisis in the airline industry.

United Airlines announced earlier this month that it was shutting four of its Red Carpet clubs at U.S. airports, after closing three others in the United States and overseas in the past few years.

Delta recently closed nine of its 47 Crown Rooms in the United States and at Gatwick Airport near London, while both American Airlines and US Airways are closing one club each.

With one exception, the U.S. carriers are continuing to serve airports where they are shutting lounges. American closed its lounge at Stansted Airport near London when it stopped flying there earlier this month.

The lounges are just one of the many targets of cost cutting by U.S. airlines as they reel from the double whammy of soaring fuel costs - which have skyrocketed more than 80 percent since last year - and a weakening economy. Carriers are also cutting capacity and staff, increasing fares and imposing new fees for everything from checking in luggage to redeeming frequent flier program mileage for free travel.

"Airlines are looking to take fixed costs out wherever they can," said William Swelbar, a research engineer at the International Center for Air Transportation at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "If a lounge is being used three, four or five times a day for only a small number of passengers, it just makes prudent sense to stop paying for it. In this high-cost environment, can I continue to offer all amenities to all people when I'm not being compensated?"

For many frequent fliers and business travelers, airport lounges have become an important place to wait out the longer times before, and between, flights, waits that have become typical in an era of increased security. Most provide free snacks and drinks, along with comfortable chairs, television, desk space and Internet connections.

Gary Chase, airline analyst for Lehman Brothers, said he believed that the "majority" of savings in the industry would come from retiring inefficient aircraft and cutting capacity. But "it is easy to underestimate the power that exists in lots of little actions," he said.

Carriers generally rent space from airports for lounges, on either a short-term or long-term basis. In addition, they must pay the salaries of lounge staff, and buy food and beverages and other services, like WiFi.

They derive some income from travelers who purchase memberships in lounge programs or passes for one-time entry to clubs. Some lounges also charge guests for alcoholic beverages and WiFi access.

United, Delta and US Airways declined to comment on their lounge closings or operation, while American declined to provide specifics on the cost structure for its Admirals Clubs, although it said that they were profitable.

In addition to the American closure at Stansted, US Airways is closing its lounge at Baltimore-Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport. In the past two years, United has closed lounges at airports in Cleveland and overseas in Sydney and at London Heathrow Airport.

By Oct. 10, it will also shut lounges at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, the Baltimore airport, Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport and Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport.

In May and June, Delta reduced the number of its clubs from two to one in Boston, and from three to two in Cincinnati, one of its hubs. It has also eliminated lounges at airports in Kansas City, Missouri; Seattle; San Juan, Puerto Rico; Phoenix, Arizona; Denver; Honolulu and at Gatwick.

At airports where they are shutting down their own lounges. United and Delta say that members can use lounges run by their alliances - Star and Sky Team, respectively - and by alliance partner airlines. Star Alliance, for example, operates a lounge at Heathrow, while Northwest, a member of the Sky Team like Delta, operates a lounge in Honolulu.

But Tim Winship, publisher of FrequentFlier.com, a Web site devoted to travel loyalty programs, says he believes that such reciprocal agreements do not always favor business travelers.

"The lounge needs to be in the same terminal as the traveler," Winship said. "Business travelers can't fritter away time schlepping from one terminal to another."

The consolidation in the airline industry might be another factor in the lounge closings. Delta and Northwest recently announced a merger, while United and Continental created a marketing and operational alliance.

"Delta's closing lounges in Seattle and Kansas City means they are saying it's not worth it to offer our own lounges, but with our merger with Northwest, maybe there are other lounges we can offer," said Henry Harteveldt, travel analyst for Forrester Research.

In addition, he interprets the decision by United and US Airways to shut down their Baltimore lounges as an admission that "Southwest is the big airline there."

The lounge closings could affect more than the travelers who belong to the clubs, who pay fees that can go as high as $450 annually for a new member. The lounges are also open to passengers who buy day passes, those who purchase certain first-class or business class air fares, to holders of elite-level credit cards, like the American Express platinum card; and to travelers who belong to the Priority Pass program, which provides access to about 500 lounges worldwide.

Many industry analysts expect the latest round of lounge closings to be permanent, as was the case with most lounges shut by airlines after Sept. 11.

Winship, for one, predicts that more closings will be announced.

The question for some business travelers is whether the airlines will lose more in good will than they will gain in savings.

The airlines will save "peanuts" in closing the lounges, said Jeff Miller, a lawyer in Columbia, Maryland, who represents travel companies. But the lost confidence, he said, "is significant."

Paul Metselaar, chairman and chief executive of Ovation Travel Group, a travel management company based in New York, agreed. "The more barriers suppliers put in front of having a comfortable travel experience, the less likely it is that business travelers will travel," he said. "To the extent that you remove these oases of calm, it's just another nail in the coffin of business travel service."

The shutdowns may provide an opportunity, however, to a few companies like Escape Airports USA, which operates a lounge at Kennedy International Airport in New York which offers food, beverages, showers and WiFi service. The lounge is open to select passengers on airlines like Asiana, and to passengers on other airlines who pay a $40 fee for one-time access.

New Fees to Drive Cost of Air Travel Sky High
Click here to go back to Top of Page

The recent introduction of new fees by many of the large U.S.-based airlines will substantially increase the price of air travel for all passengers and can add significant costs to one’s family vacation. For example, new fees from rising fuel costs can increase the cost of an airline ticket by more than $150. There are also new or steeper fees to check the first piece of luggage, the second, and all additional bags, not to mention buying water or soda on a flight and redeeming frequent flyer miles.

In addition to the cost, imagine the extra time these transactions will take. In the future, travelers should expect to arrive well in advance of standard one hour for domestic flights and two hours for international flights due to the time involved in handling and paying for the luggage as well as the inevitable disputes that will arise when passengers indicate they were not advised of the charges.

The flight attendants on US Airways will probably have the most stressful and demanding job following the implementation of fees for sodas and water. They will have to determine if a passenger is entitled to “free” water because they are dehydrated as opposed to charging them $2 for a bottle. The flight attendants will also have the obligation of collecting the fee, which adds to their already stressful duties and slows down the beverage service for everyone on the flight.

It’s no surprise that Southwest has begun a national advertising campaign to promote the fact that it is essentially fee-less, including no charge if a passenger changes a ticket on Southwest, other than to pay the then-current fare. On some of the legacy carriers, the charge is as high $150 just to change a ticket before paying any additional fees due to a change in pricing. Southwest will also check two pieces of luggage per passenger without charging a fee. Most sodas and other in-flight beverages continue to be free. We have to wonder why any passenger would fly a carrier other than Southwest or some of the low-fare airlines if they operate in one’s market.

The cruise lines have already reacted to the increased cost of flying by moving some of their fleet to convenient “drive-to” markets. Examples include Norwegian Cruise Line’s many departures out of New York City and Carnival’s repositioning of a ship to Baltimore beginning in the fall of 2009 for year-round service.

We recommend to our travel agency clients that they advise their clients, in writing, of the additional fees if they are traveling on airlines that have implemented or increased these types of charges, even if some of the fees will be paid at the time of departure or on the flight such as beverages. For a family traveling with children, the additional fees can add a significant cost to their round-trip vacation.

There is little doubt that some of the legacy carriers will be in bankruptcy by the end of the year. That, of course, will raise other liability issues for our travel agency clients. The most important issue for the travel agency community is to remain up-to-date on all developments in order to provide the best advice and guidance to clients regarding new or increased fees.

Credit Cards, Travel Insurance Essential in Wake of Airline Bankruptcies
Click here to go back to Top of Page

The recent bankruptcy filings by four airlines have raised a number of questions for our travel agency clients with regard to protecting passengers who may be holding tickets on an airline that has gone into bankruptcy and, in several instances, shut down operations.

The best protection under these circumstances is for the passenger to charge the airline tickets on a credit card so the charge can be reversed or, if it has not been paid yet, the traveler should not pay it. In most instances, the Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act provides protection for purchases for which the services are not delivered. Unfortunately, the passenger would still not receive the air transportation but at least they would be reimbursed for the cost of the airfare.

A second alternative is to sell travel insurance. However, many travel industry insurance carriers exclude either specific suppliers from default protection or do not provide default protection if a vendor goes into bankruptcy.

Further, neither cancellation/change fee waivers or cancellation/trip interruption insurance will protect the passenger in the event of a bankruptcy. In trip cancellation/change fee waivers, the vendor simply waives their cancellation/change penalty if the passenger needs to cancel/change before they depart. Under most waivers, the ability to do so only applies up until a few days before departure. At that point, if the passenger cancels, the normal penalty applies. The waiver must be purchased at the time the deposit is made and it cannot be added later. It is not insurance and it does not cover supplier default.

Trip cancellation/interruption policies can include trip cancellation/interruption, trip delay protection, baggage protection, medical coverage, emergency evacuation, and assistance. Some policies also include clauses for the traveler’s voluntary cancellation, which provides a partial credit toward future travel in lieu of non-refundable cancellation fees.

Insurance offered by the suppliers, even through a third-party vendor, does not include default protection because the vendor cannot sell insurance where they are insuring against their own actions.

Inevitably, some clients will lose deposits and/or payments and ultimately try to recoup their losses from the travel agency. We strongly recommend that our agency clients undertake an internal audit to evaluate and take steps to limit the agency’s risk as much as possible. This includes reviewing the agency’s organizational structure, including whether it is a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, LLP, or LLC. The agency needs to review its current corporate structure with its CPA and/or attorney to determine which form of ownership best suits its needs.

Agencies should also review their use of disclaimers in the sale of travel insurance. Enhanced training programs should be mandatory for employees and available to independent contractors and home-based agents to make certain that disclaimers are routinely used and travel insurance offered on every sale.

We also strongly recommend that the agency include in its disclaimer a recommendation that the client use a credit card for payment. However, under no circumstances should a travel agency guarantee their client’s funds are protected if they charge the payment to a credit card. We merely recommend that agencies suggest to their clients that a credit card might provide more protection than cash or writing a check when paying for travel arrangements.

It is also essential that the agency has written authorization, such as a signature, e-mail, or fax, authorizing the credit card charge. If the sale involves airline tickets that are processed through ARC, the agency must follow the procedures outlined in the Industry Agents’ Handbook, which specifies what is accepted by each credit card company and airline for a credit card charge. If the travel agency follows these steps, it will have no liability in the event of any chargebacks or disputes by the passenger. Alternatively, if it does not follow those procedures and the passenger stops payment, it is likely the agency will be issued a debit memo.

We strongly recommend that all agencies take precautions to avoid possible economic loss associated with the current financial conditions of many travel industry vendors.

Click here for past articles